Safest Areas in and Around Indianapolis

Whether you are relocating to central Indiana, buying your first home, or searching for a peaceful community for your family, neighborhood safety is often one of the most important considerations. Indianapolis is a fast-growing city with a mix of historic districts, suburban neighborhoods, and family-friendly communities that consistently earn high marks for safety and stability.

In this guide, we highlight some of the safest areas in and around Indianapolis based on public crime data, long-term neighborhood trends, and resident feedback.

Related: Indianapolis Crime Rate Statistics

How We Identified Indianapolis’s Safest Neighborhoods

These selections are based on multi-year crime trends reported by the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department, as well as comparative insights from the FBI Crime Data Explorer and local safety analysis tools such as NeighborhoodScout and AreaVibes. We also reviewed indirect safety indicators like school access, lighting, walkability, neighborhood investment, and resident involvement.

While no area is completely free of crime, the neighborhoods below consistently show lower-than-average incident rates and are often highlighted for their strong community atmosphere.

Safest Areas in and Around Indianapolis

Meridian Hills

Located on the north side of Indianapolis, Meridian Hills is known for its quiet streets, established homes, and wooded surroundings. The area benefits from long-term residents, high homeownership, and a strong emphasis on neighborhood pride. With high-rated schools nearby and a suburban feel within city limits, Meridian Hills consistently ranks as one of the safest communities in the Indianapolis metro area.

Williams Creek

Just north of Meridian Hills, Williams Creek is a small, affluent residential area known for its large homes, scenic environment, and strong community involvement. With a very low volume of reported crime and an active neighborhood association, Williams Creek attracts families and professionals seeking privacy and long-term stability.

Broad Ripple (Select Areas)

Broad Ripple is one of Indianapolis’s most popular cultural districts, offering a mix of nightlife, parks, and riverside amenities. While the village core is lively, many surrounding residential pockets experience significantly lower crime than the city average. These areas benefit from high walkability, active neighborhood organizations, and frequent community engagement. Proximity to the Monon Trail adds to the appeal for families and outdoor enthusiasts.

Zionsville

Located just northwest of Indianapolis, Zionsville consistently ranks as one of the safest communities in the region. Its brick-lined Main Street, strong school district, and active homeowners make it a highly desirable suburb. Long-term crime data shows low rates of both violent and property crime, supported by a dedicated local police department and engaged residents.

Carmel

Carmel is one of Indiana’s highest-rated cities for safety, quality of life, and suburban amenities. With award-winning schools, extensive trails and parks, and well-planned residential developments, Carmel has built a strong reputation for low crime. The area’s commitment to community investment, lighting, and infrastructure contributes to stable, safe neighborhoods across the city.

Fishers

Fishers, located northeast of Indianapolis, is another consistently safe suburb known for top-tier schools, walkable neighborhoods, and active local government programs. The city’s emphasis on community engagement, public events, and neighborhood maintenance supports low crime rates and high resident satisfaction.

You Might Also Like: Dangerous Areas in Indianapolis

What Makes These Neighborhoods Safer

Across the Indianapolis metro area, safer neighborhoods tend to share several characteristics:

• Active resident groups and community events
  
• Higher homeownership rates and long-term residents
  
• Well-lit streets and walkable pathways
  
• Quality schools, parks, and recreational facilities
  
• Strong police-community relationships
  
• Careful community planning and development standards

These qualities help build trust, consistency, and shared responsibility within the community.

Best Practices for Keeping a Safe Neighborhood Safe

Even in low-crime areas, everyday habits help maintain safety and peace of mind. Residents can support their neighborhood’s safety by:

• Keeping porches and entryways well lit
  
• Using a video doorbell or outdoor security cameras
  
• Locking doors, windows, and vehicles consistently
  
• Joining neighborhood forums, watch groups, or local associations
  
• Reporting suspicious activity quickly
  
• Maintaining clear sightlines around yards and entry points

A strong safety culture develops when neighbors stay engaged and aware.

For You: Top Neighborhood Watch Apps 

How Guardian Protection Can Help

Even in Indianapolis’s safest neighborhoods, an added layer of protection can help secure your home and provide greater peace of mind. Guardian Protection offers smart home security systems designed for reliable monitoring and rapid alerts.

Our security solutions include:

• Indoor and outdoor security cameras
  
• Door and window sensors
  
• Smart home control and mobile app management
  
• Professional monitoring for fast response

Explore Guardian’s services in your area: Home Security in Indianapolis

Strengthening Peace of Mind at Home

Choosing a safe neighborhood is one of the best steps you can take for your home and family. Guardian Protection helps extend that peace of mind by providing reliable, easy-to-use home security solutions designed for everyday protection.

Ready to enhance your home’s safety? Get a free quote or call 800.857.5028 today.